The Identity Theft side mission in Batman: Arkham City stands out as one of the most compelling detective storylines in the game. Players must search the sprawling megastructure to locate three distinct crime scenes left behind by a calculating killer. Tracking down each victim requires a keen eye, precise use of Detective Mode, and a clear understanding of how story triggers function across the campaign.
Finding the First Victim Near the Courthouse
The initial crime scene becomes available early in the campaign after completing main story events near Solomon Wayne Courthouse. You can locate the first victim lying in an alleyway just north of the courthouse building, surrounded by medical bandages. Investigating the body using Detective Mode reveals forensic evidence, including blood traces and surgical cuts, that kickstarts the case file.
Scanning the evidence allows Batman to reconstruct the crime scene and establish a forensic profile of the killer. Players who stay tuned to daily gaming news often highlight this mission for its excellent integration of classic comic lore and investigative mechanics. Following the initial blood trail leads to a dead end, signaling that further story progression is required before the next clue appears.
Locating the Second Victim in the Industrial District
The second victim only triggers after progressing further into the main narrative and leaving the Museum. Head to the Industrial District and search the alleyways near the outer wall to the southeast of the Ferris wheel. Here, you will discover another body with a face wrapped entirely in bandages, matching the exact modus operandi of the first murder.
Using Detective Mode on this second body uncovers fresh forensic evidence, including a unique knife blade and distinctive skin residue. Scanning these items updates your criminal database and provides deeper insight into the suspect's surgical expertise. Once the scan completes, Oracle logs the findings, setting up the final stage of the investigation.
Uncovering the Third Victim and Tracking the Suspect
The final victim surfaces near the Bowery district, tucked away in an alley near the GCPD building after completing the Wonder Tower campaign events. Finding this third body confirms that the killer is harvesting facial features to construct an exact likeness of Bruce Wayne. Scanning the final set of clues unlocks the precise location of the killer's hidden hideout within the city.
Following the signal coordinates leads Batman straight to an unmarked apartment building in the Bowery. Entering the hideout reveals a creepy makeshift operating room complete with surgical tools, audio logs, and harvested skin samples. Confronting Thomas Elliot, also known as Hush, resolves the side quest while leaving a major cliffhanger for future Arkham installments.
Tips for Completing the Identity Theft Questline
To avoid frustration, remember that each victim body only spawns after reaching specific milestones in the main storyline. Scanning every piece of evidence thoroughly ensures that the quest markers update correctly on your map. Completing this investigation is essential for players aiming to achieve 100% completion in Batman: Arkham City.
